Whose Criticism Should You Actually Take Seriously?
Pliny the Elder tells a story about Apelles, a celebrated painter in Alexander’s time. After finishing a painting, Apelles displayed it in public and listened unseen to people’s reactions, believing others could spot what he missed because he was too close to his work. One day, a shoemaker pointed out that a painted shoe was missing a strap. Apelles corrected it. When the shoemaker returned the next day and began criticising the leg, Apelles told him to stick to what he knew: a shoemaker should not judge beyond the shoe. Both parts of the story matter. The shoemaker noticed a real mistake because he understood shoes, but that did not make him an expert on anatomy. The value of criticism depends less on the critic’s status than on whether they know the subject they are judging. Writers and artists often receive feedback from people with no credentials attached. Whose criticism have you acted on, and what did that person know that you didn’t?
Stories are shared by community members. This article does not represent the official view of NaijaWorld — the author is solely responsible for its content.

